There’s Only One Good Reason The Doctor Doesn’t Show Up In Doctor Who’s New Show

Anybody hoping to see the Physician within the new Physician Who spin-off Warfare on Land and Sea can be upset. Not solely do Time Lords not seem, they’re solely talked about a number of instances all through the sequence. Typically, Warfare on Land and Sea steers the sequence away from aliens and time journey and into the realm of extra down-to-earth political drama, albeit one with fishmen.

The Physician’s absence advantages The Battle of Land and Sea, permitting it to exist as a present in its personal proper and spotlighting sturdy characters like Berkeley, Salt, and Kate Lethbridge-Stewart. However explaining why The Physician would not seem in canon phrases is one other matter completely, and though there are many excuses on the desk, just one really is smart.

The previous Physician Who excuses for the Physician’s disappearance now not maintain up.

It is not like Physician Who hasn’t run into this downside earlier than. Earlier spin-offs Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures revolved completely across the concept of ​​who would shield Earth within the Physician’s absence. On the time, the rationale for the Physician’s no-show was comparatively easy. They could not be in all places on a regular basis. Torchwood or Sarah Jane Smith needed to shield Earth whereas the Physician rescued the bees in Rasha Coricophala Patrias.

It was a clear and efficient clarification to get the Physician out of the best way. Sadly, it can’t be utilized in land and sea wars.

Even ignoring Billie Piper’s incarnation of the Physician, Physician Who’s sixtieth anniversary ended with the 14th Physician taking over everlasting residence on Earth after two generations. Even higher, this Physician was capable of hold the TARDIS and one way or the other ran a second technology of his personal.

The Physician is stationed on Earth, geared up with a TARDIS to take care of any threats. Some may argue that Fourteen did not present up towards Stek as a result of he was uncovered to the Mud, and that he did not battle Rani as a result of he obtained caught up within the Want World. However when plastic begins raining down on Earth and Homo aqua makes aggressive land-based strikes, Fourteen will doubtless don’t have any selection however to reply.

That is the nook that Physician Who has written itself into with the ending of The Fourteenth Physician, and it means the sequence can now not hold making the excuse that “The Physician wasn’t there” each time another person saves the Earth. The physician is all the time there.

Excuses for conflict between land and sea additionally do not work.

Warfare on Land and Sea gives its personal argument as to why the Physician would not trouble to assist Homo Aqua. The spin-off claims that the Time Lord’s function is to guard Earth, not information it.

Whereas which may be true more often than not, it is value remembering that at varied factors in Physician Who’s historical past the Physician has acted as an middleman between humanity and Homo Aqua or its Silurian cousins. Whether or not negotiating straight or guiding human representatives, the Physician has by no means shied away from serving to Earth’s native species construct peace.

Even within the time of the Twelfth Physician, we have seen time vacationers attempt to dealer a truce between people and Zygons, so there is not any cause the Physician would not a minimum of have an interest within the arrival of Homo Aqua through the Warfare on Land and Sea. Not that UNIT did not admire the Physician’s assist.

The one logical cause why medical doctors do not assist Homo Aqua

It’s inconceivable that a minimum of one Physician (the 14th, sixteenth, or each) was unaware of the Homo Aqua scenario creating on Earth. Witnessing this collision between land and sea, the Physician will need to have made a acutely aware resolution to not become involved.

They need viewers to consider that this resolution was made as a result of in a conflict between land and sea, Earth wants to face by itself two ft with out Time Lord interference or something like that. As an alternative, it makes extra sense for the Physician to doubt their capability to result in significant change.

As talked about above, The Physician has interceded with each the Silurians and the Sea Demons on behalf of humanity in varied iterations, however this mediation has by no means really had a optimistic finish end result. The Third Physician’s encounter with the Silurian ended within the bloodbath of Brigadier Common Lethbridge-Stewart. The Fifth Physician’s interactions with the Silurians and She-Devils additionally led to genocide.

One might argue that the Eleventh Physician achieved higher success, however regardless of this, humanity has continued to pollute the Earth within the years since.

So the one actual clarification for the Physician’s absence from Physician Who’s Battle of Land and Sea is that he genuinely believes the Time Lords can not help them – that inserting themselves into the scenario will both result in extra violence or, at greatest, don’t have any impact. In different phrases, the Physician is so enraged by the altercation between the people and the Silurian/Homo Aqua that they’ve given up on serving to us.